Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has indicated that increasing payments to failed asylum seekers to encourage voluntary return could be cost-effective for taxpayers. The announcement comes as part of a broader overhaul of the UK asylum system.
Voluntary Return as a Cost-Saving Measure
Speaking to BBC Radio 4, Mahmood explained that supporting failed asylum seekers currently costs the government approximately £30,000 per person per year. She argued that offering cash incentives, potentially higher than the current upper limit of £3,000-could reduce long-term expenditure while encouraging voluntary departures.
“A voluntary return is often the best way to get people to return to their home country as quickly as possible,” she said.
“It may stick in the craw of some people, but it works and is value for money for the taxpayer.”
Pilot programs are already underway to test the impact of larger payments on return rates.
Removal of Families Who Refuse to Leave
The government’s proposals also allow for the deportation of families with children who have had their asylum claims rejected, even if they initially refuse to leave voluntarily.
Some Labour MPs and peers have criticized this policy. Lord Dubs, a Kindertransport survivor, described it as “weaponizing children.” Mahmood responded firmly:
“I would never use children as a weapon. My duty is to prevent putting children in danger, such as crossing the Channel on unsafe small boats.”
She emphasized that while children’s welfare is carefully considered, failed asylum seekers cannot remain indefinitely at the taxpayer’s expense simply because they have children.
Contributions and Asset Considerations
The proposals also address the wealth and assets of asylum seekers. While sentimental items such as wedding rings will not be confiscated, high-value items like luxury watches, vehicles, or other assets may be taken into account to offset the cost of accommodation and support.
Mahmood explained:
“Most British citizens contribute to the cost of accessing benefits, and asylum seekers should be treated similarly if they have assets.”
The goal is to create a fair system that balances humanitarian support with responsible use of public funds.
How LawSentis Can Help
At LawSentis, we are closely monitoring these major asylum reforms. Our UK-based, IAA-regulated immigration specialists can help you:
-
Understand how new rules on voluntary return, payments, and deportation of families affect asylum seekers
-
Navigate eligibility and compliance requirements under the updated asylum system
-
Advise on potential legal pathways and protections for those affected
-
Prepare documentation to ensure full adherence to Home Office regulations
If you or someone you know is impacted by these changes, book a consultation with LawSentis today to receive professional guidance and secure the best course of action under UK asylum law.